Why Do Some Good Policies Gain Momentum Faster than Others?

Sustainable agriculture
Garniasih Garnijanto30.10.2026
In October 2026, a shared challenge recently united officials from Subulussalam and Aceh Selatan at the Regional Development Planning Agency of Aceh Singkil to learn from the district’s track record. “How can districts accelerate the issuance of Cultivation Registration Certificate (STDB) for independent smallholder farmers?” In the room, a shared conclusion quickly took shape. Not only was there a solid four-year experience, but strong coordination and trust were cultivated through Aceh Singkil’s Multi-Stakeholder Platform (MSP), which helped turn collaboration into practical results. Further progress then comes from taking hands-on action to dismantle hurdles that prevent good systems from functioning as intended.

In essence, STDB helps districts build a clearer picture of their agricultural sector and strengthens the traceability increasingly demanded throughout global supply chains. Companies gain greater confidence that the palm oil they source can be linked to identifiable producers and responsible practices. And for smallholder farmers, the benefits are more immediate. An STDB is a gateway to opportunities that would otherwise remain out of reach, such as government support, replanting programs, financial services, and sustainability certification schemes like RSPO. The certification allows smallholders to participate more fully in a premium market.

Moving decisions closer to the people doing the work

Over the years, districts across Indonesia have faced a familiar reality. The process of translating requirements into completed registrations can be resource-intensive. Yusfarizal, Division Head at the Aceh Singkil Plantation Office, has spent the last four years learning how to efficiently close this gap. According to him, understanding the regulations thoroughly is key. But what is more important is finding practical ways to execute them.

The district’s breakthrough came from choosing agility over authority. Previously, approvals required sign-off at the regency level. Aceh Singkil transferred authority to the Head of the Plantation Office, allowing decisions to move closer to the people responsible for implementation. Similar principles applied elsewhere. Rather than waiting for villages to submit documents, the district proactively communicated with village heads and encouraged them to prepare administrative requirements in advance. The district also developed practical data-collection forms that mirrored the fields required in the digital e-STDB platform, making subsequent data entry more efficient.

Aceh Singkil made other institutional changes with a series of practical measures to make implementation easier. Seeking to strengthen supply-chain traceability, the Aceh Singkil Plantation Office proposed a Regent's Circular Letter encouraging palm oil mills to ensure that independent smallholders supplying fresh fruit bunches (FFB) hold an STDB, in line with Minister of Agriculture Regulation No. 98 of 2013. Development partners were registered in the e-STDB system so they could support farmer data entry. Operational staff adopted simple habits, such as using mobile phones to routinely monitor the digital platform, helping issues to be identified and addressed more quickly. These seemingly modest adjustments reduced administrative bottlenecks and kept the registration process moving forward. “Before I retire in 2031, I envision every farmer to recognise the importance of STDB. Simply put: No STDB, no sending fresh fruit bunches to the mill,” Yusfarizal stated.

A key lesson that has everything to do with trust

Implemented by Swisscontact Indonesia and Earthworm Foundation, the Sustainable Landscape Program Indonesia in the Leuser Alas-Singkil River-basin (SLPI-LASR) has actively developed a close working relationship between Aceh Singkil and members of its Multi-Stakeholder Platform (MSP). In fact, one of the main reasons the district is able to accelerate STDB issuance is the strong coordination established through the MSP.

"Having coordinated development partners made the process much easier. It was supported by palm oil mills and concession holders, and further strengthened by a letter delegating authority from the Regent."
Yusfarizal, Division Head at the Aceh Singkil Plantation Office

Collaboration emerges as a recurring theme throughout Aceh Singkil's experience. Registered development partners supporting farmers can help input available farmer data into the e-STDB system, allowing government officials to focus on verification and document checking. An increase in efficiency, but only because trust exists. Without trust between the district’s Plantation Office and MSP members, this type of collaboration would be difficult. It also demonstrates that an MSP can go beyond a forum for discussion. As a working system, when roles and relationships are established, collaboration becomes a practical mechanism for solving implementation bottlenecks.

Replicating success: Learnings that travel, lead to action

Yusfarizal's four years of accumulated experience are creating value beyond Aceh Singkil. They offer a resource for others on how solutions are applied in practice. The inter-district exchange generated momentum for joint follow-up action. Aceh Selatan has already identified opportunities for collaborative efforts to advance e-STDB issuance in at least two villages before the end of the year. 

"The exchange has been very encouraging. It guides us from the start of data collection all the way to the certification issuance. We are optimistic to empower 500 palm oil smallholders in our area to secure their STDB in 2027."
Rusmarita, SP., Head of the Plantation Division, Aceh Selatan Agricultural Office

This is how progress accelerates, and experiences are scaled. Years of implementation from one district help neighbouring areas move faster, avoid similar bottlenecks, and focus their energy on solutions that are proven effective. The STDB acceleration in Aceh Singkil shows that implementation succeeds when people find practical ways to make systems work. This includes proactive government leadership, practical administrative solutions, capable partners, and above all, trust and collaboration. A remarkably simple formula sums it up: real sharing, real efforts, real results.

The Sustainable Landscape Program Indonesia in the Leuser Alas-Singkil River-basin Landscape (SLPI-LASR) is co-funded by the Swiss State Secretariat for Economic Affairs (SECO) and is implemented by Swisscontact in Indonesia and the Earthworm Foundation.

2023 - 2029
Indonesia
Sustainable agriculture
Sustainable Landscape Program Indonesia (SLPI-LASR)
The Sustainable Landscape Program Indonesia (SLPI-LASR) unites the local government, private companies, and rural communities to balance economic growth and governance with environmental protection. A race to protect one of the world’s most critical ecosystems in Aceh and sustain livelihoods before forests fall silent.